Hi, Joshuasq. I can't say for certain, but I have received documents in which the paragraph mark (pilcrow) has more than meets the eye. As you may know, the pilcrow stores all the formatting info for the paragraph. If there are unaccepted track changes, or mixed-up style problems, I have seen selection of the lower of two paragraphs, for instance, also select the one above. Usually this can be cleared by either reapplying the style to both, or deleting the in-between paragraph and replacing it. See if that does it.

Best,
Ulo