Yeah, nah! You need to post the actual document rather than screenshots if you want a simple answer, otherwise we need to guess at what is going on and talk back and forth to zero in on the issue.

The paragraph settings you are showing in your screen shots doesn't reflect the settings on the paragraph which has extended to the left. That paragraph in particular has a hanging indent which is not shown in that dialog screenshot. We also can't see the page margins, the ruler or page setup in your screenshots.

Firstly, try selecting all that text and apply a different style to it - I would choose Normal or Body Text. If that doesn't change the alignment, click on it and see if there is a frame that appears around it. If you click to the left of the second line, does a frame appear showing that there might be a white object sitting there?

__________________
Andrew Lockton
Chrysalis Design, Melbourne Australia