I'm having a problem with the autmatic numbering of figures in a document. It may have been caused by copying and pasting captioned/numbered figures from another document. The first figure already has a caption on the preceeding page which says Figure 1 but I wanted to label it on the page where it's present; this says Figure 2, however. If I try to make a new caption for this figure, it's referred to as Figure 4?!

(click to enlarge)